Provenance is a big deal with originals. Who was the soldier? A lot of collectors want to know the name of the soldier, his unit, and all of that important information. However, buying named militaria can backfire on you if you don’t know anything about the items.
There are many ways that WWII veterans acquired military-esque equipment that was not originally theirs. During the 1950′s and 60′s, many veterans bought Army surplus that they knew was durable and would work for hunting, fishing, and camping. 50 years later, memories often blur with what they brought home, and what they purchased at an Army surplus store after the war. This may sound silly, but you must remember that in the 1940′s and 50′s, for many families practical items were used until they were thrown out. Grandpa’s original web belt may have torn or worn out, so he went and bought a new one at the Army surplus store to carry his bait.
In addition, veterans often purchased civilian items modeled after military patterns . Again, because the Army made quality, long lasting gear, it only makes sense that some of it was made in a civilian grade by the same manufacturers and sold to fishermen, hunters, campers, and boy scout groups. To confuse things more, recently a slew of collectors items have been targeted at veterans. These items are typically easy to spot, because of their modern designs, but sometimes are nothing more than a replica or copy of a original WWII item. Here are some tips to make sure you’re buying what you think you’re buying.
1. Look for stencils and serial numbers that match the service member. If his name is Paul, and his bag is marked Jim, chances are it’s not a mistake by the Army, but rather a post war acquisition or purchase. It’s hard to know if it’s uncle Jim’s bag, or the bag that Paul bought at the Army Surplus to keep his sleeping in when he went hunting. If this is not important to you, and you can authenticate it in other ways, then it’s still a perfectly fine item, just not named to the veteran in question.
2. Verify that it is, in fact, US Army issue. My grandmother was notorious for giving me things that “your grandfather brought this home after the war”. About half the items were clearly purchased in the 1960′s or later, and were obviously civilian items. Suspicious items include shovels, knives, bags, jackets, and assorted other equipment. Keep on the lookout for Boy Scout markings.
3. Be weary of items that could easily be replaced with modern reproductions. Medals, patches, ribbon bars and rank all fall into this category. Men who had put their uniforms away, or wore them for hunting until they were threadbare, often later in life started volunteering with veterans organizations and desired replacement uniforms, complete with re-issued insignia. Other than knowing the difference between modern and vintage rank and ribbons, be wary of uniforms that come with American Legion or other veteran organization markings or caps.
4. Be sure you authenticate flight jackets and field jackets prior to purchase. These are probably the most common item that I find on ebay is the A-2 jacket that “belonged to my father who served in the USAAF” and yet they are 80′s or 90′s civilian jackets. In these cases, patches, nose art, leather name patches, or even silk maps sewn in the inside are far from being clues to the authenticity of the jacket. Veterans commonly have their long lost WWII flight jackets recreated by artists or flight jacket companies.
5. Collectible items are usually easily recognized, but in general the best tip is to look for Franklin Mint or other collectable markings. If something is marked No. 50 out of 400, it is not a trench art or wwii era souvenir piece. Here, common items are things like men’s jewelry boxes, coins, and statuettes.
Understand that most veterans and children of veterans are not out to fool anyone intentionally. Just like my grandmother who wanted to give me all of my grandfather’s stuff, even if it’s a green rain poncho that you can buy at any camping store, these people all have good intentions. It’s your job to make sure that what you are buying is authentic, and authentically named.